By Jordan Berendt
“They’re ruining baseball by changing the game.”
This is a phrase that MLB fans, players, and coaches hear all too often nowadays. Particularly, since the MLB introduced what is often referred to as the automatic “ghost runner” rule in 2020, nostalgic baseball supporters have not held back from voicing their complaints.
The automatic runner rule was added during the 2020 season as part of the MLB’s attempt to shorten games and reduce players’ exposure to one another in the midst of a global pandemic. This rule consists of placing a runner on second base at the start of each extra inning during regular season games. Despite the initial mixed fan reactions to this change, many baseball lovers refused to believe the rule would last much past 2020.
However, as the pandemic slowly subsided and the world returned to a new normal, the rule still remained. This sparked further debate over whether having a “ghost runner” was changing the beloved game of baseball. Despite critics’ arguments, the rule was permanently implemented by the MLB prior to the 2023 season.
So, just like life after the pandemic, can’t fans adjust to this rule being the “new normal” in baseball?
The answer for many – no.
Unfortunately, the quote “change is scary” resonates far too closely with several long-time baseball fans.
I would argue, however, what these OG baseball fanatics desperately need to hear is this – CHANGE IS NECESSARY!
Similar to how educational curriculums, the English language, people, and many more things evolve, sports do too. Now, more than ever, Major League Baseball is in need of changes like the “ghost runner” rule to appeal to younger audiences. Audiences that will make up the future of baseball.
Considering this rule is now official, fans might as well try and focus on the positives. Below, I have listed five advantages of the automatic runner rule that baseball purists should consider next time they feel compelled to complain.
Shorter Games
Many fans and players have come to appreciate how the automatic runner rule has significantly decreased the length of games. While the average MLB game time in 2019 was three hours and five minutes, a typical game was just two hours and 36 minutes in 2024.
Additionally, there is no denying that this shorter game time has increased younger generations’ appeal for the game. According to the American Psychology Society, all people, but especially children, have attention spans that are continually shrinking. One of the major contributors to this is our ever-growing digital world.
So, let me ask you this, what fun would extra innings be if nobody is there at the end of the game to see the outcome?
Increased Scoring
Beginning extra innings with a runner starting on second leads teams to a greater chance of scoring. This fact has been proven throughout the last four years ever since the automatic runner rule was implemented. Today, teams are scoring closer to two runs on average in a single extra inning, a big improvement in most player’s eyes.
Healthier Players
The longer the game, the more strain players suffer. As a result, injuries are more likely to occur and starting players are replaced by those who typically sit the bench.
Since making the “ghost runner” rule permanent, all players, especially pitchers, have seen a reduced risk of injury and are facing less physically taxing circumstances. Moreover, because pitchers are experiencing less pain, the negative effects of an extra inning game do not carry on for days and no longer mess with team’s pitching rotations.
Elimination of Marathon Games
In baseball, marathon games refer to games that extend into 15 innings or more. While those who oppose the automatic runner rule often favor the nostalgia associated with a 17-inning game, most people today simply do not have the time or patience to wait these games out.
As technology has progressed, distractions have increased, and people’s abilities to multitask have slowly dwindled. Marathon games are not practical in today’s society.
More Action
Lastly, who wants to go to an MLB game and see only one or two runs scored? Not me. Because the automatic runner rule has helped increase scoring in extra innings, fans are likely to get more bang for their buck in terms of entertainment. This rule has also added a new layer of unpredictability to the game, forcing teams to strategize like never before.
Ultimately, if the reasons above are not enough to convince you that the automatic runner rule is part of the facelift that Major League Baseball needs, then I am afraid you might be stuck in the past.
While it is understandable that many adults feel deeply connected to the “traditional” game of baseball, change is both necessary and inevitable. It is time that professional baseball lovers start accepting this and prioritizing the future of the game.
As every loyal MLB fan knows, “There’s no crying in baseball!”
